In this controlled assessment I am going to be showing how love and hate are shown in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, and also comparing it to Robert Browning’s poems. I will be looking at how these two authors show similarities such as the context it has, the contrasts. Also I will be trying to compare any language devices in these two authors and try to develop them in how they show love and hate.
In Julius Caesar I know there is love between three characters they are: Julius Caesar, Brutus and Cassius. At the start of the play Caesar comes back from a battle against Pompey and all the people of Rome are cheering him. However Cassius explains himself to Brutus in how he feels, this is shown in when Cassius tries to persuade Brutus to kill Caesar because they both believe that Caesar will over use his power and become a tyrant, this is also seen where Brutus says “what means this shouting? I do fear the people choose Caesar for their king” Brutus says that he agrees with what he (Cassius) says but does not know if he should betray his best and closest friend, which is Julius Caesar. Cassius replies “Ay, do you fear it?Then must I think you would not have it so” Shakespeare shows hate towards Julius Caesar through Brutus as he makes Cassius persuade him and turn against him. Cassius also starts a soliloquy and says ” Thy honourable mettle may be wrought”. This is showing the audience that Cassius says Brutus’s mettle may be wrought which means that he will change the way he feels for Caesar . Cassius then waits for Brutus to reply in an aggressive manner towards Caesar but he doesn’t , Brutus still refers to his love for Caesar as he says “I would not, Cassius, yet I love him so well.”In my opinion this starts to show hatred towards Brutus from Cassius because he is trying to get a reaction out of Brutus however it is just not working in Cassius’s favor.
Referring to Porphyria’s lover, I believe there is a contrasting of the love shown in the two texts. A twisted love, this is because in act 3 scene 2 Brutus gives his memorable speech of saying that “Not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more.” I believe that Shakespeare is using persuasive language to show love and also to show why Brutus has chosen Caesar s fate. On the other hand I believe that twisted love is also shown in Porphyria’s lover when her lover decides to strangle her and kill Porphyria with her own hair how ever I do not think that Porphyria’s lover did it for a greater good, he had no reason to do it but the lover could have possibly done it because he thought he could have done what he wanted with her as she took care of him. Where as Brutus says he killed Caesar for the good of Rome. Also I believe that there was dramatic effect in Brutus’s speech as it is a soliloquy to all the public which will give him a mix of emotions and it leaves the reader thinking what is going to happen next.
In act 2 scene 1 of Julius Caesar Brutus starts a soliloquy of by saying to the crowd “It must be by his death”. This look and sounds like hate because he expresses his feelings in a dull way and it sounds like he has a massive hate towards Caesar. How ever in the next sentence he says “And for my part I know no personal cause to spurn at him but for the general.” He infers that he has no reason to hate him. On the other hand towards the end of the soliloquy he says “And therefore think him as a serpents egg(which, hatch’d,would as his kind grow mischievous) and kill him in the shell. From this soliloquy I can infer that love can quickly flip over to hate as he says “And for my part I know no personal cause to spurn him”. This shows that Brutus had no intention of doing it but only for the generals sake he is going to, this also shows sympathy as he does not really have a choice to do what he did as he over thinks about the love he has for Caesar before killing him. Moreover the way Shakespeare makes us see it is that it is either leaving Caesar to have become a tyrant, or kill him and save Rome by doing so. And Brutus would always have chosen Rome over Caesar as he says later on in the play “not that I loved Caesar less, but that I loved Rome more.” What I found helpful in this part of the play is that Shakespeare uses imagery when referring to Caesar as a serpents egg, I feel this way because when describing some one as a serpents egg, they think that they will grow up to have a fierce characteristic and when growing up it will have more power and will be a lone wolf controlling what it wants how it wants. This is why Brutus says “which, hatch’d would as his kind grow mischievous and kill him in the shell.” This shows that they want to kill Caesar because he will use his powers in tyrannous ways which will ruin Rome.
Looking back at the poem ” The Laboratory”, I think that there are some similar trends and patterns in comparison with act 2 scene 1 of Julius Caesar. This is because in the laboratory there is a dilemma where a women is speaking to an apothecary(a person who sells medicine and drugs). And from looking at the second stanza, the character who is talking clearly has some jealousy over a person she loves. Robert Browning also uses rhythm which lets the reader read at its own pace and will have their own under standing of the play. The rhythm is in the last word of every sentence for example it says “He is with her, and they know I know where they are, what they do: they believe my tears flow”. It also shows the emotion that is in this part of the poem as the narrator has some sort of jealousy and hate towards the two people that are in a relationship. What is also used in this part of the second stanza is enjambment, this increases the speed of the rhythm and also shows emotion of the narrator, this shows anger and hate as the narrator is speeding up and is trying to get his emotions out as fast as he can. This gives a clear understanding to the audience about the theme of hate and how its portrayed. Also in the tenth stanza there are these three sentences which give the reader a very clear understanding of what is going on, also alliteration is used in these sentences “Let death be felt and the proof remain: Brand, burn up, bite into its grace—He is sure to remember her dying face!”. This gives a range of different emotions but I think it emphasizes hate the most, this is because of the verbs it uses and it shows what she wants to do to her. She wants to torture her as much as she and make her feel as much pain as she can. This also shows unrequited love because the narrator loves the other character however she does not love him.
Soliloquy of the Spanish cloister is a poem where there are two monks who really hate each other and the narrator is jealous of the other monk. The narrator says “if hate killed men, Brother Lawrence, God’s blood, would not mine kill you!”. This again has an emotion of hate and anger because he is saying that if his hate could kill men , Brother Lawrence I would kill you. This also sounds like the two monks have not liked each other from the past because the hate seems to have built up and the monk cannot take it anymore. This could be linked with Julius Caesar when Cassius always seems to hold a grudge against Julius Caesar. This is also an another poem from Robert Browning that involves love and hate, but what is unusual is that monks tend to love each other more than anything and that they are also calm and humble people. They also tend to live with each other most of their lives and in Robert Browning’s poem it is completely different.
To conclude, I think that William Shakespeare and Robert Browning have similar feelings towards their writing however they express the emotions in different ways. I believe that in Julius Caesar there was more of a mixture between love and hate, however in Robert Browning’s poems there was either deep love, or hate shown and made it clearer to understand what is going on. More over William Shakespeare lived in the fifteenth and sixteenth century which people could have expressed and shown love in different ways than other time periods. Robert Browning lived in the eighteenth century which is over hundreds of years of a difference to these two amazing writers, this could have led to different ways to show love and hate as William Shakespeare wrote mostly plays and Robert Browning wrote poems.

Recent Comments